Canadian Criminal Procedure and Practice/Cases/Guilty Pleas
Withdraw of Guilty Plea
[edit | edit source]| Case | Citation | Result | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| R. v. Wiebe | 2012 BCCA 519 (CanLII) | denied | |
| R v Lewis | 2012 SKCA 81 (CanLII) | accepted | accused changed plea with lawyer on day of trial--never admitted offence--appeared confused |
| R. v. Williams | 2012 BCCA 314 | denied | |
| R. v. Sutton | 2012 NLCA 35 | accepted | |
| R. v. Downes | 2012 ONCJ 45 | denied | |
| R. v. Greenall and Collins | 2011 BCPC 28 | withdraw denied | |
| Lamontagne | 2011 QCCA 1486 | GP upheld | |
| R. v. Chisholm | 2010 ONSC 3877 | denied | argued that was not given an option but to plead guilty |
| R v Messervey | 2010 NSCA 55 | ||
| R v White | 2009 NSSC 313 | ||
| R. v. Maniaol, | 2009 ABPC 390 | granted | withdraw permitted due to misapprehension on admission of intent. Accused believed he was admitting willful blindness in intent when plea required actual intent.(see R. v. Maniaol, 2009 ABPC 390 at para 23) |
| R. v. McCollum | 2008 NSCA 36 | ||
| R v DWS | 2008 BCCA 453 | upheld | |
| R. v. K.D.H., | 2007 ABPC 264 | withdraw granted | |
| R v Leonard | 2007 SKCA 128 | updheld | |
| R. v. Nevin, | 2006 NSCA 72 | ||
| R. v. Dodge | 2005 NSPC 24 | guilty plea withdrawn due to false acceptance to help another (see para 22 to 25) | |
| R. v. Moore | 2004 BCPC 560 | withdraw denied | |
| R v Gold | 2004 BCCA 179 | ||
| R v. McIntosh | 2004 NSCA 19 | ||
| R v Barry | 2004 NSCA 145 | ||
| R. v. Wetmore | 2003 ABQB 350 | denied | |
| R. v. Hallam | 2003 BCPC 201 | withdraw denied | |
| R. v. Moser | 2002 CanLII 49649 (ON SC) | withdraw denied | |
| R v Hector | 2000 CanLII 5725 (ON CA) | upheld | |
| R v Clermont | 1996 NSJ 170 | ||
| R. v. Pottie | 1996 CanLII 5604 | ||
| R v Murphy | 1995 CanLII 4329, [1995] N.S.J. No.41 at 10 | ||
| R v. S.K. | 1995 CanLII 8926 (ON CA) | granted | |
| R v. Morris | 1994 CanLII 1669 (BC CA) | granted | |
| Porter | 1994 132 NSR 107 | ||
| R v. R.T. | 1992 CanLII 2834 (ON CA), (1992) 10 OR (3d) 514 (Ont. C.A.) | appeal dismissed | |
| R. v. Gautreau | 1991 CanLII 4232 (NB CA) | dismissed | appeal of failed withdraw dismissed - plea with experienced counsel and confirmed in court |
| R. v. Rubenstein | 1987 CanLII 2834 (ON CA) | denied | guilty plea made with counsel; joint statement of fact submitted. Joint recommendation was rejected; |
| R v Melanson | 1983 NSJ 453 | ||
| R v Igoe | 1982 54 NSR 113 | ||
| MacNeil | 1982 51 NSR 2d 541 | ||
| R. v. Hansen | 1977 ManCA |