GCSE Modern History/Cuba
The Cuban Revolution
[edit | edit source]How did the USA react to Batista's government being overthrown?
[edit | edit source]- Initially, there was a frosty relationship but with no direct confrontation.
- In 1960, the USA banned buying of Cuban sugar (July) and then banned all trade with Cuba (October).
- In January 1961 the USA broke off diplomatic relations.
- After the takeover, Castro took over American businesses, but let them keep the naval base.
- In April 1961 the USA supported an invasion of Cuba by exiles (the Bay of Pigs). It failed.
The Bay of Pigs
[edit | edit source]Why was the Bay of Pigs invasion a failure?
[edit | edit source]- The CIA underestimated Castro's popularity - the Cubans did not rise to support the invasion.
- The invasion convinced Castro that the USA was an enemy and made him look to the USSR for support and protection.
- Kennedy claimed that there was no direct American government involvement, but Castro and Khrushchev knew the CIA had planned it and trained/armed the exiles.
- The failed invasion made Castro even more popular.
- Because of the failed invasion, Khrushchev was able to put missiles on Cuba claiming that they were for defensive purposes.
- A force of 1400 exiles landed in Cuba and were killed/captured by 20 000 Cuban troops.
- The USSR gave Castro and his men weapons and arms.
The Cuban Missile Crisis
[edit | edit source]Why did the Soviet Union put missiles on Cuba?
[edit | edit source]There are a number of theories as to why the Soviet Union decided to put missiles on Cuba. Some of these are:
- To get the upper hand in the arms race.
- They genuinely wanted to defend Cuba.
- To bargain with the USA (e.g. make them remove their missiles in Turkey).
- To test the USA.
- They wanted to trap the USA.
Why was the USA concerned about Soviet missiles on Cuba?
[edit | edit source]“ |
The estimate was that within a few minutes of [the missiles] being fired 80 million Americans would be dead. |
” |
There are a number of reasons for which the USA was concerned about Soviet missiles on Cuba. Some of these are:
- There was the potential for a nuclear war that would have destroyed the USA.
- Cuba was becoming a powerful country in their 'sphere of influence'
- The USSR could use the missiles to bargain with the USA and make them remove their nuclear missiles from Turkey.
- They were worried that the USSR was trying to draw them into a nuclear war.
- It was a test that would show how strong the USA really was.
- It was a threat to USA supremacy in the arms race.
The USA's Actions
[edit | edit source]Kennedy had a number of choices as to what course of action to take. The main ones were:
- Doing nothing would make the USA seem weak and ineffective, and would not solve the problem. However, there would be no risk of war.
- A blockade would prevent more nuclear weapons arriving but did not solve the root of the problem, and would make the USA seem weak if it failed.
- An invasion of Cuba would get rid of Castro but risked starting a war with the Soviet Union.
- Diplomatic pressure would not risk the outbreak of war, but would make the USA seem weak if it failed.
- A surgical air attack would result in a Soviet response (Berlin?) and could not guarantee the destruction of all the missiles.
The Outcome
[edit | edit source]“ |
We behaved with dignity and forced the United States to demobilise and to recognise Cuba. |
” |
— Khrushchev in his memoirs (1971) |
“ |
President Kennedy will be remembered as the President who helped bring the thaw in the Cold War. |
” |
— Kennedy's obituary in The Guardian (1963) |
There has been much debate about who came out victorious of the Cuban Missile Crisis. You should draw your own conclusions, but keep the following points in mind:
- After the failure of the Bay of Pigs, Kennedy was able to claim success.
- Khrushchev's reputation was damaged, and he was overthrown by his opponents in 1964.
- The Cuban Missile Crisis made some steps towards better relations:
- A 'hotline' was set up to allow better communication between the leaders.
- In 1963 a Nuclear Test Ban Treaty was signed.
- Cuba remained Communist and highly armed, and was a useful base for Soviet operations in South America.
- Khrushchev claimed that he had ensured the safety of his ally, and made peace.
- Khrushchev got the USA to remove its nuclear missiles from Turkey, but this was kept secret so it couldn't be used for propaganda purposes.
Was the Cuban Missile Crisis really a threat to world peace?
[edit | edit source]Historians argue whether the Cuban Missile Crisis was really a threat to world peace. Some points to think about are:
- Both leaders were ready to negotiate. After the crisis, they even set up a direct telephone line to discuss any future crisis. - This shows the countries were equally ready to contribute and suggests that neither leader wanted to start a war.
- If Khrushchev was to be believed, the missiles were only for defensive purposes.
- Advisers on both sides were suggesting a war.
- Castro wanted Khrushchev to open fire first, but Khrushchev wanted to negotiate with the USA.
- Neither leader wanted to start a war.