Transportation Deployment Casebook/2019/Sydney Metro

QUALITATIVE ASSESSMENT

INTRODUCTION

The selected mode for this assignment is the railway network, especially Sydney Metro railway services. The first passenger railway line in NSW opened on September 26, 1855. The link was made from present day Central Station to Granville Railway Station (Parramatta Junction). This link consisted of 4 intermediate stations, Newtown, Ashfield, Burwood and Homebush. The oldest NSW railway construction is the over-bridge located in Ultimo, it currently provides access for the transportations of goods from Sydney Railway yard to Darling Harbour Goods Yard.

The expansion of the railway network in the mid 1800s was predominantly due to European settlement. A railway line from Blue Mountains to Bathurst and South Highlands to Goulburn was necessary for farming and pastoralism. The network slowly developed to carry passengers in the mid 1800s. In 1890, the network expanded to the North Shore from Hornsby to St Leonards specifically for suburban use.

PRIOR TO TRAINS

Prior to the arrival of steam engine trains in the early 1800s in America, the Australian roads were still being developed. After the British Colonisation in 1778, the road networks, buildings and land regulations had to be established from scratch. The main source of trade for the early British settlers were farming and pastoralism. Hence, horse-drawn carts and wagons were predominantly used for carrying heavy loads. Additionally, since most Australian settlements were along the coast of the island, steamboats were also a popular mode of import and export across the states and countries.

The Australian road network was a blank canvas for the British developers. They were able to learn from the pre-existing roads in Britain and were able to make the Australian roads a lot larger. In saying that, the limitations behind gravel roads were that the roughness of the road made it difficult to transports goods safely.

Most of the Australian transportation ideas were evolved from the US or Britain. In America, the early 1800s were a time when wooden rail-road were introduced. They soon learnt that wood was very fragile and wore off in a short period of time. It was soon after when steel tracks were introduced, and steam operated carriages were pulled from one city to another to transport goods. Eventually, these carriages evolved to transport passengers and some companies used this opportunity to make a profit. Railroads minimised travel time by 90% and many people in the US moved to the west. Australia adopted this idea and implemented cargo and passenger carriages altogether in 1855.

In NSW alone, between 1870 and 1880, the passenger traveling increased from 776,707 to 5,440,138.

INVENTION & TECHNOLOGY

James Watts from Scotland was the first to invent the steam engine with an active piston. In 1804, the first working steam railway locomotive was introduced in the UK. 1812 was the year when the US identified the opportunity to transport good as well as personal travel using this mode. Hence, work began on the construction of the first rail roads in North America in 1815. The Baltimore and Ohio railroad was constructed in 1828. In 1830, the Liverpool and Manchester railroad was opened in the UK. Not only passengers, mail and parcels were also being picked up and delivered using the railroads. Up until this point, all rail roads were wooden, in the mid 1850s steel rails started to emerge.

Since more and more rail roads started to emerge, there had to be a system put in place to schedule the trains. 1868 was the year when the knuckle and pin coupler was invented. This allowed the carriages to be switched around with ease. 1869, the transcontinental railroad was built in the US. This was the most advanced technological advancement of the time.

In 1869, the air brake system was invented by George Westinghouse which was later implemented in the steam engine trains. Electrical signalling was implemented in 1870 to schedule trains better. These switches and lights allowed for more trains at a certain period of time as well as increased passenger access. As the years went by, trains were adapted to suit the environment. This included, noise reduction technologies, passenger comfort and faster cargo delivery.

EARLY MARKET DEVELOPMENT

The early 20th century was when electric powered locomotives started to peak interest in many developers and businesses. Australia adapted the diesel-electric locomotive technology in 1926. This technology made it easier to adapt to the different time zones in Australia as well as air quality was improved in major cities and town. NSW was becoming more and more developed post world war 2, hence industrial leaders took this opportunity to expand the Sydney Metro network as the demand for it increased. Car train (shorter trains) were popular between 1993 to 2005. As the demand increased, the NSW government started introducing larger trains with greater passenger capacity. The Waratah A Sets series in operation today have the total capacity of 624 people. When comparing the reason why trains were used in the mid 1800s and now, it is notable that there are other means of transport for goods, thus, trains are only at the highest demand in cities for short distance travels (<50 km).

POLICY IN THE BIRTHING PHASE

The NSW railway track built in 1855 was a 22 km railroad stretching from Central to Granville. As the project faced financial difficulties, the NSW colonial government took the project over. As a result of different companies’ construction railroads all across Australia, the railway gauges differed in every state. The colonial government’s standard gauge size was approximately 1600mm. However, some parts of Queensland and Western Australia had different gauge length for their tracks.

The standardisation of gauge commenced in the 1930s after the introduction of the electric powered trains. The new standard gauge length was 1435mm. Only in 2004 the standard gauge had finished applying all over Australia.

GROWTH OF THE MODE

After running on steam engines for almost a century, Dr John Bradfield was the first to introduce the idea of electric trains in Sydney. The timeline of this is as follows:

1926 – Electric trains began operating in the Illawarra line. St James and Museum Stations were opened.

1932 – Trains started operating through the Sydney Harbour Bridge

1956 – The city circle was complete with the opening of Circular Quay station

1979 – More networks were established in the Eastern suburbs all the way to Bondi Junction.

2000 – To accommodate for the Sydney Olympics, a new line was opened connecting Olympic Park Station to Sydney Airport.

2009 - New link from Epping to Chatswood was opened.

2015 – A whole new area of Sydney, the South west, opened its first ever railway link.

Now the Sydney Metro, owned and operated by TfNSW, has provided convenience and comfort for daily passengers and tourists. The network is established in a way that is close to many business districts and tourist attractions. The main market for Sydney Metro are daily commuters getting to work, school children and tourists. Peak hour times are between 8am – 10am and 4pm – 7pm weekdays. The network aims to connect more and more people to Sydney Central as it is developing more work and leisure opportunities.

MATURE PHASE

Sydney Trains has been operating the suburban rail services since 2013. Weekly there are more than 1 million passenger journeys recorded. There are 306 stations in New South Wales with over 2080 km of tracks. Due to the lack of demand for these trains during the night, some links do not operate between midnight and 4:30am. All trains are DC powered with 1500 V running above them. The system is designed in such a way that boarding and alighting times are minimised to approximately 15 seconds for optimal use of scheduling. The 2014 timetable change for Sydney Metro allows for more frequent trains, and there is a guarantee that a train will be on a platform every 15 mins or less.

In future prospect, there have been talks of expanding the NSW trains to bullet trains for faster access. However, this idea may not be feasible as people would rather fly or drive long distances due to comfort.

QUANTITATIVE ASSESSMENT

DATA

Data from 1855- 2013 was found for annual passenger journeys in the Sydney Metro lines. This data was extrapolated from graphs obtained from TfNSW annual reports. The following is the quantitative analysis of this data. S(t) = K/[1+exp(-b(t-t0)]

where:

·        S(t) - is the number of passenger journeys per year

·        t - year

·        t₀ is the inflection year

·        K is saturation status level

·        b is a coefficient.

YEAR	PASSENGER JOURNEYS- MILLIONS
1855	0.052
1856	0.06
1857	0.05
1858	0.06
1859	0.05
1860	0.049
1861	0.046
1862	0.042
1863	0.0397
1864	0.037
1865	0.033
1866	0.03
1867	0.027
1868	0.024
1869	0.02
1870	0.017
1871	0.28
1872	1.14
1873	1.42
1874	1.84
1875	2.25
1876	3.22
1877	3.41
1878	3.88
1879	4.72
1880	5.26
1881	5.43
1882	5.92
1883	6.03
1884	6.61
1885	7.29
1886	7.46
1887	7.93
1888	8.06
1889	8.62
1890	9.24
1891	9.50
1892	9.95
1893	10.62
1894	11.24
1895	11.91
1896	12.98
1897	13.95
1898	15.05
1899	16.33
1900	17.62
1901	19.30
1902	21.37
1903	23.82
1904	26.39
1905	28.98
1906	31.25
1907	33.43
1908	36.19
1909	38.98
1910	41.55
1911	44.90
1912	53.85
1913	58.43
1914	67.34
1915	71.91
1916	80.76
1917	85.39
1918	89.96
1919	94.31
1920	98.58
1921	106.10
1922	109.17
1923	111.87
1924	114.92
1925	117.73
1926	121.22
1927	125.01
1928	128.35
1929	131.59
1930	135.25
1931	138.19
1932	141.01
1933	143.73
1934	146.76
1935	149.59
1936	152.90
1937	156.44
1938	160.37
1939	164.46
1940	168.41
1941	173.13
1942	187.38
1943	191.83
1944	205.73
1945	220.24
1946	229.73
1947	233.03
1948	235.75
1949	238.93
1950	242.21
1951	249.73
1952	253.60
1953	257.53
1954	261.87
1955	265.40
1956	263.88
1957	261.28
1958	259.20
1959	256.75
1960	254.30
1961	253.30
1962	256.42
1963	260.97
1964	263.63
1965	261.27
1966	257.85
1967	255.36
1968	252.68
1969	249.99
1970	252.65
1971	247.33
1972	224.66
1973	200.95
1974	197.79
1975	186.83
1976	181.21
1977	180.44
1978	180.21
1979	185.76
1980	206.60
1981	210.88
1982	206.97
1983	202.22
1984	199.08
1985	205.63
1986	219.49
1987	224.60
1988	245.57
1989	248.33
1990	251.08
1991	248.80
1992	239.59
1993	231.78
1994	241.51
1995	251.37
1996	259.89
1997	264.79
1998	267.70
1999	276.44
2000	280.53
2001	282.04
2002	267.53
2003	264.61
2004	263.25
2005	261.12
2006	268.25
2007	273.06
2008	287.79
2009	291.64
2010	290.91
2011	299.89
2012	304.74
2013	307.50

Table 1: Raw Data (Source - transport.nsw.gov.au)

MODELLING

K is estimated to be 1000 million journeys by year 2100. Using linear regression t0 was found to be 1907, and intercept b = 0.2156. The following graph portrays the predicted passenger journey growth up until 2100. Predicted (ORANGE CURVE), Actual (BLUE CURVE)

(Graph is emailed as it was unable to be uploaded)

ANALYSIS

The graph consists of the quantitative analysis of Year Vs Passenger Journey in the Sydney Metro line. According to the graph, it is clear that there is a gradual increase in the number of journeys over the decades. However, some fluctuations are visible in the more recent year, perhaps due to more innovate mode of transport emerging. An S- Curve was developed to forecast the number of passenger journeys up until 2100. The linear regression method used to predict the S-curve is not wholly accurate as the K value was assumed based on previous year’s results. However, the S-curve model is used to estimate many growths in technology advancements in research reports. In saying that, one can never accurately predict the growth of a mode based on pure assumptions.